Prime Day 2025: What Retailers Must Learn Before the Holidays
S5E8 Decoding the Hidden Truths Behind Amazon Prime Day with Meghan Barden
We’re cutting through the clutter in retail strategy, technology & leadership to help you achieve the best results for your business from retail operations to customer experiences. Subscribe today! Stay sharp. Stay human. Stay ahead!
Missed our previous edition? Find it here → The Future of Retail Events is Here — Curated, Connected, and AI-First
We welcome back Krystina Gustafson, Co-founder & Chief Content Officer of RetailClub. Krystina joins us to offer an insider’s look at RetailClub’s AI Deepdive Retreat event — a groundbreaking event curated to reshape the concept of the retail conference and foster retail's first AI-native community.
Prime Day Unveiled: Trends, Sales, and What Lies Ahead for Retail
Prime Day 2025 broke records — but the real story is in the data. Meghan Barden, Director of Global Retail Media at Rithum, joins us on the latest episode of The Retail Razor Show to decode what it means for retail, ecommerce, and your Q4 strategy.
Meghan brings over 20 years of experience in marketing and retail media strategies to our discussion, making for a captivating conversation about the retail shopping holiday.
We sat down with Meghan to unpack what this year’s Prime Day shopping holiday event revealed about consumer behavior, retail strategy, and what’s coming next for ecommerce leaders heading into the holiday shopping season.
Let’s be clear: Prime Day isn’t just a mid‑year sales event for Amazon anymore. It’s a strategic litmus test for Q4 across all retailers — and this year, it sent some unexpected signals.
📊 The Numbers That Matter
Per Adobe’s Prime Day report, U.S. retailers drove $24.1 billion in online spend from July 8 (Tuesday) to July 11 (Friday), representing 30.3% growth year-over-year (YoY). This is more than two Black Fridays—which drove $10.8 billion in online spend during the 2024 holiday shopping season—and sets a new benchmark for the summer shopping season.
Additional points on Prime Day Meghan discussed with us on the show and shared via Rithum’s Prime Day Lessons report.:
Average order value decreased year over year from almost $60 down to $56
Day 1 saw the largest consumer spend; with a downward trend for Day 2 and 3 and a slight increase on Day 4 as shoppers decided to hit buy on their carts from the previous 2 days
More competition from retailers this year across the entire week (Walmart, Target, Best Buy, Nordstrom Anniversary Sale, to name a few)
Essentials outperformed discretionary categories - clothing & accessories, and home & garden GMV down (43% and 23% respectively)
📈 Unveiling New Trends and Generational Shifts
This year’s Prime Day was notably unique, with its important shift in scheduling —occurring right after the 4th of July.
Meghan points out, “...people may have spent their discretionary spending over that holiday weekend, whether that's shopping, traveling, et cetera. And then they go into Prime Day and may not have had that discretionary spending that they typically had the week following.”
Extending the sale from two days to four also didn’t result in the expected boost in sales, highlighting a crucial trend: consumers are becoming more savvy in their purchasing decisions.
Notably, Meghan shared, “the overall average order value dollar amount went down year over year [from] almost $60 to $56,” signifying a more cautious approach from consumers.
She also observed trends in product categories, with staples and home essentials like cleaning supplies and home decor seeing an uptick despite a generally challenging economic climate.
Meghan also noted that while spend was up across retailers, conversion rates lagged across many marketplaces until the final push — a sign that shoppers are more deliberate, comparing offers before committing.
👧The Power of Gen Z
The conversation also steered towards generational differences in shopping behaviors.
Meghan asserts, “Gen Z is this top emerging purchase group… going to have immense buying power.”
This generation approaches retail with a digital-first mindset, placing heavy emphasis on brand authenticity and values. Unlike previous generations, Gen Z is less swayed by urgency or discounts and is more influenced by brand narratives and environmentally conscious practices.
As retailers prepare for future sales events, Meghan advises, “retailers need to hone in on what they do best, where they are most authentic…”
This emphasis on authenticity is critical for connecting with Gen Z and avoiding the overwhelming noise of an over-saturated retail space.
🛍 Prime Day’s New Role in Retail Strategy
“Prime Day isn’t the Super Bowl anymore — it’s the preseason.” — Meghan Barden
Retailers used the event as a testing ground for back‑to‑school and holiday strategies. With Walmart, Target, and Nordstrom running overlapping sales, consumer attention was fragmented. Many brands approached Prime Day with calculated caution — liquidating summer inventory, testing creative, and gauging demand elasticity.
🔮 What It Means for Holiday Shopping
Deal‑savvy, inflation‑aware consumers will shop across multiple events
Timing matters — post‑July 4th placement may shift discretionary spend
Agility wins — inventory, pricing, and marketplace optimization will be decisive
Meghan emphasized that brands should now be fine‑tuning retail media strategies, adjusting promotional calendars, and preparing for a holiday season where consumer loyalty will be earned through relevance and responsiveness.
🧠 Thoughts on the Role of AI and Emerging Technologies
We also explore the role of AI in retail, with Meghan discussing its application in campaign management and consumer shopping behaviors. As consumers become more cautious, retailers who leverage AI for more personalized and strategic planning will set themselves apart in the holiday season and beyond.
🎧 Final Thoughts and an Invitation
The depth of insights from Meghan Barden make this episode a must-watch for anyone invested in retail strategies and consumer behavior analysis. With profound discussions on shopper data, Gen Z’s impact, and AI’s role, this episode arms you with knowledge to anticipate and adapt to ongoing changes in retail.
If you’re a retail strategist, ecommerce operator, or just obsessed with the science behind big shopping events, this episode delivers insights you can act on now.
Tune in to the full season 5 episode 8 and subscribe to our podcast to learn more about the shifting dynamics of retail and how Amazon Prime Day is setting the stage for the future of retail shopping events!
Until next time! Stay sharp. Stay human. Stay ahead!
Sincerely,
Ricardo Belmar & Casey Golden
Co-hosts of The Retail Razor Show
On the next edition of The Retail Razor Newsletter…
We shift our focus to The Retail Razor: Retail Transformers podcast and talk with a legendary retailer and industry expert often called the Fairy Godmother of Retail!
We speak with Vicki Cantrell, retail strategist and community builder, recognized for relationship building and accelerated growth, founder of Vendors in Partnership and the Vendors in Partnership (VIP) Awards celebrating partnerships between retailers and solution providers to create a joint community of these industry experts to advance retail innovation. Vicki shares her experiences throughout her amazing retail career and delivers insights on how building community and relationships is what the future of retail will be built on. Don’t miss this important Retail Transformers episode!
Thank You for Your Support!
Have you heard of Goodpods yet? If you haven’t, give it a try as your podcast player and join our podcasting community!
As we continue Season 5, we’re honored and humbled to be the only retail podcast in the Top 10 All-time Management Podcasts charts on Goodpods!
We’re also excited to continue our Goodpods success reaching
the #1 spot on the Top Indie Management weekly podcast charts,
the #1 spot on the Top Indie Marketing weekly podcast charts,
plus two podcasts in the Goodpods Top 100 All-time Career Podcasts chart!
We'd love your support to help us stay at the top by giving us a five-star rating and review on Apple Podcasts, Goodpods, or Spotify.
The Retail Razor Podcast Network
The Retail Razor Show is part of The Retail Razor Podcast Network alongside our other shows:
Please leave us feedback by posting your comments to Notes on Substack, Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube, or Goodpods.
Support us on Goodpods.
Connect with us on LinkedIn.
Subscribe & watch on YouTube.
Follow us on Instagram, Threads, Bluesky, and Facebook.
For a full transcript of this episode, visit our Retail Razor Podcast Network website!